The A’s Should Trade Jim Johnson To Tampa Bay For Grant Balfour

Billy Beane made some great trades to bolster his Relief Core - and rotation for the 2014 year.  Unfortunately 1 move may haunt in more ways than 1 in Jim Johnson.

Billy Beane made some great trades to bolster his Relief Core – and rotation for the 2014 year last winter. Unfortunately 1 move may haunt in more ways than 1 in Jim Johnson.

Billy Beane just hasn’t been on the bad end of many deals in his recent days.  Trading for Jim Johnson may turn out to be his worst move ever.

Originally it looked like another genius move, trading away an MiLB player in Jemile Weeks – for a guy who has back to back 50 Save seasons on his resume, but it has been a colossal nightmare for the AL Bay Area franchise.

Johnson was given a 1 YR deal worth $10 MIL.  This represents about 12% of the team total payroll of just over $80 MIL for the 2014 campaign.

The dollars doled out hurts the team more than anything else.  Had this man just been inept, without carrying a heavy price tag, it would have been a 4th and 40 situation (think what you do in football in that scenario.

What is too bad is that Beane actually looks smart in not giving Grant Balfour his cash for the kind of deal he wanted either.

Jim Johnson had 2 losses in his 1st 2 appearances of the year, which both were held at o.co coliseum, which certainly din't endear him to his new faithful fans in the Bay Area.  Johnson has been plagued by nearly 2 baserunners per inning worked.  Having 101 Saves in the last 2 years to lead both campaigns may have been entirely misleading to what this guy was like.  The A's are paying him about 12% of their entire payroll - for him to put forth these horrible numbers.  There is one trade partner that Oakland may be able to coax into a deal, and that is Tampa Bay, who has former A's Closer Grant Balfour having a similar year to Johnson.

Jim Johnson had 2 losses in his 1st 2 appearances of the year, which both were held at o.co coliseum, which certainly didn’t endear him to his new faithful fans in the Bay Area. Johnson has been plagued by nearly 2 baserunners per inning worked. Having 101 Saves in the last 2 years to lead both campaigns may have been entirely misleading to what this guy was like. The A’s are paying him about 12% of their entire payroll – for him to put forth these horrible numbers. There is one trade partner that Oakland may be able to coax into a deal, and that is Tampa Bay, who has former A’s Closer Grant Balfour having a similar year to Johnson.

Both Johnson and Balfour have lost their Closer Roles on their respective squads.

With the Athletics, Sean Doolittle has assumed the position now – and had been incredible.

The converted 1B, has a 50 SO/1 BB Walk ratio, which is about 250% better than any one Pitcher in the history of the MLB.

The big LHP has 10 Saves, a crisp 2.00 ERA, and a brilliant 0.583 WHIP in 36 IP.  There is no way this guy is relinquishing the role if he keeps this up.

The best part is that Doolittle just signed a 5 YR deal worth only $10.5 MIL, which is only 500K more than Johnson for the one year he is authoring in 2014.

My idea is simple.  Trade Jim Johnson, plus $2 MIL for Grant Balfour.

Balfour is due about $2 MIL in 2014, and then pockets $7 MIL in 2015. That is an aggregate total of $9 MIL for the next 16 months.

Johnson has about $5.5 MIL left on his deal this season.  I am sure like the A’s, the Rays are wishing they had not signed a new Closer like Balfour.

Heck, the club shouldn’t have traded Alex Torres for Logan Forsythe either, but that is beside the point.

Pro’s for the deal.

– Tampa saves $3.5 MIL for the collective 16 months, which is huge considering the team is not in contention this campaign, and may look to salvage some cash back by trading Veterans.

– Oakland has 2 Relievers coming off of the books after this season in Luke Gregerson and Eric O’Flaherty.  While the latter has not pitched yet, Gregerson has thrown well in any position in the Relief Core not named the Closer.

Balfour was a money deal for the previous stint with the A’s.  With the money looking flushed down the toilet for Johnson already, the sum of acquiring the Aussie back would only cost $3.5 more for the next 1 year and a half.

– The 36 Year Old RHP would not have to be the Closer, but he fits into the clubhouse, the fans simply relish this guy, and he could help the Bullpen if it works out. As it stands right now, Johnson has a near 2 WHIP in his frames for Oakland this year, and can’t be trusted.

– Balfour would be given chances by Bob Melvin to resurrect his season, and I am sure he would love to come back and take care of some unfinished business = winning a playoff series as part of the Pitching Staff.

Ryan Cook has been fighting injuries all year with an elbow strain and sore shoulder, and having another quality right hander like the club’s former Closer couldn’t hurt.

Besides Doolittle and Cook, the team has Fernando Abad, Dan Otero and Fernando Rodriguez under team control for several more years.

Of course, the Tommy John recoveries of A.J. Griffin and Jarrod Parker may see a better fit to work out of the Relief Core in the middle of next year as well – rather than throw a lot of innings as a Starter in early stages of coming back tot the staff again.

Balfour’s 2014 year has been a weird one for sure.

After a handful of scoreless appearances, the man gave up a 5 ER performance to the Yankees on April.17, and then yielded another 5 ER to the White Sox just 8 days later.

In all, he has appeared in 29 Games, and only given up runs in 6 of those games, accounting for the 18 ER, and a ballooned ERA of 5.52.

Recently, he has thrown 3 straight scoreless Innings, fanning 6 guys in that time frame.

As bad as it has been early, the Aussie has only surrendered 2 HRs in his 29.1 Innings worth of work.  Also good is surrendering just 22 Hits, but what is brutal is the Walking of 18 others – contributing to a WHIP a 1.462, where his career mark is 1.202 presently.

When Relievers have a bad start to a year it takes forever for their numbers to fall within good parameters again, and sometimes they never recover for the season at all.

It may be worth exploring this kind of trade for Beane.  He should try to act quick though, as the more good efforts Balfour puts forth, it will rise the radar of other teams for a prospective trade.

Although at this day of June.24, it looks like a badly advised move to pick up $9 MIL remaining on the RHP’s 2014 – 2015 combined salary.

The deal may also work out for Jim Johnson – who has a career highlighted by working out of the vaunted AL East, and to be away from the unforgiving A’s fans – who have never embraced the 30 Year Old, originally from Johnson, NY.

To the fans credit, the 2 time reigning AL Saves leader got off to just an abysmal beginning with his new team, losing both of his 1st 2 games he entered, and blowing a Save Opportunity in his 2nd outing.

Johnson’s production mirrors that of Balfour for all things, IP, BB, HRs Allowed, ERA – meanwhile he had given up 41 Hits in 30.2 IP – which is horrible.

But the Rays aren’t going anywhere in 2014, and maybe they will start trading away veterans to assemble a new core among young talent.  What better way, than to shave off $3.5 MIL off of your bottom line in the next 2 years!

The Rays can find players within their system to take over for the departed Balfour next year.

Unless Tampa reels off a 21 – 4 stretch like they did about this time last year, this season is likely already over for the Rays.

These 2 teams are perfectly situated to pull off this maneuver.

Heck, even if Johnson is released after a few weeks, $3.5 MIL back in the pockets of the brass should be able to land them another Reliever or 2 for 2015.

For all of the Rosters, Depth Charts, State of the Unions and Salaries Posts that we do, please visit our dedicated page link here.

The "Balfour Rage" was celebrated big time by the Oakland fans during his successful 3 year run with the franchise, were he broke Dennis Eckersley consecutive Saves Team Record gathered a 2.53 ERA (all 3 campaigns under 3.00) with a 1.043 WHIP, during his 64 Saves and 100.2 Innings authored.  When you look at his gamelogs, it may just be a simple risk.  Beane should payout a little more money in pending salary (Balfour makes approx $9 MIL from now until 2015's end, while Johnson is due about $5.5 left this year.  Since TB is not in the running this year, they should hold onto as much cash as they can heading into next year.  A trade such as this would give them $3.5 MIL more for next year.

The “Balfour Rage” was celebrated big time by the Oakland fans during his successful 3 year run with the franchise, were he broke Dennis Eckersley consecutive Saves Team Record gathered a 2.53 ERA (all 3 campaigns under 3.00) with a 1.043 WHIP, during his 64 Saves and 100.2 Innings authored. When you look at his gamelogs, it may just be a simple risk. Beane should payout a little more money in pending salary (Balfour makes approx $9 MIL from now until 2015’s end, while Johnson is due about $5.5 left this year. – before he will be a Free Agent.   Since TB is not in the running this year, they should hold onto as much cash as they can heading into next year. A trade such as this would give them $3.5 MIL more for next year.

** The views and opinions expressed in this report are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of mlbreports.com or their partners.***

a oak 2

Chuck Booth – Lead Baseball Analyst/Website Owner and author of the Fastest 30 Ballgames:   To learn more about my  “The Fastest 30 Ballgames Book” and how to purchase it, click here .

You can reach me on Twitter 

Please e-mail me  at: mlbreports@gmail.com with any questions and feedback.  To subscribe to our website and have the Daily Reports sent directly to your inbox, click here and follow the link at the top of our homepage.

Advertisements

About chuckbooth3023

I played competitive baseball until 18 years old and had offers to play NCAA Division 1 University Baseball at Liberty University. Post-concussion symptoms from previous football and baseball head injuries forced me to retire by age 19. After two nearly made World Record Attempts in 2008, I set a New World Record by visiting all 30 MLB Parks (from 1st to last pitch) in only 24 Calendar Days in the summer 0f 2009. In April of 2012, I established yet another new GWR by visiting all 30 Parks in only 23 Calendar Days! You can see the full schedule at the page of the www.mlbreports.com/gwr-tracker . In 2015, I watched 224 MLB Games, spanning all 30 MLB Parks in 183 Days. Read about that World Record Journey at http://mlbreports.com/183in2015/229sked2015/
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to The A’s Should Trade Jim Johnson To Tampa Bay For Grant Balfour

  1. Pingback: The A’s Should Trade Jim Johnson To Tampa Bay For Grant Balfour « The AustralianBaseballDigest

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s